This is the story of what really happened. This is the truth.
When Emma moved to Orsonville back in the third grade, Anna introduced herself. They soon became fast friends, and Emma hasn’t really spent time with anyone else. Now the girls are in ninth grade, and the glamorous and edgy Mariah has introduced them to her circle of friends, broadening their social horizons greatly. One night the girls tell their parents that they’re going to the movies when really they’re going to Mariah’s boyfriend’s house for a party. They get caught in this lie by their parents and make up another, bigger one, to cover it up: they were on their way to the movies but took some time to just hang out by the river. When they were at the river, a strange man attacked them. They managed to escape, but never made it to the movies.
When the girls tell the lie, they think it will get them off the hook and that will be that. Instead, their parents get the police involved, their school holds assemblies to discuss the event, a man is arrested, and the women of the community stage a “Take Back the Night” rally.
In Harmless, Dana Reinhardt tells the story using each of the girls’ voices. We get a different perspective from each of them and learn their motivations and see what their lives are like from the inside. This unique form of narration allows each girl to be a whole character, rather than limiting us to one girl’s perspective on the other two. We also see how each character changes: Anna, the good and unpopular girl, decides to open up and finally start being a little wild; Emma, the “normal” one, withdraws into herself; Mariah, who has always been rebellious, starts to take life more seriously.
Harmless is very different from Reinhardt’s first book, A Brief Chapter in My Impossible Life. The tone is darker, though the subject matter is of equal seriousness. Harmless is, above all else, intense. It examines what can happen when we lose control of our lies. It also shows us that people may not be just the way you perceive them. Mariah’s inner thoughts reveal her to be not at all the girl Anna thought she was. Emma’s family has secrets she doesn’t share, even with her best friends. Anna has a desire to be different than she is, but doesn’t express this until Mariah presents her with the opportunity.
Harmless is an excellent book. I would recommend it to readers who like books that make them think. It contains language and content that make the YOUNG ADULT label necessary and emphatic: parents may want to read it before giving it to their children.
Book: Harmless (Affiliate Link)
Author: Dana Reinhardt
Publisher: Wendy Lamb Books
Original Publication Date: 2006
Pages: 240
Age Range: Young Adult
Source of Book: Borders
Other Blog Reviews: Big A little a, propernoun.net, interactivereader, Becky’s Book Reviews, Sara’s Holds Shelf, Kids Lit, I’m A Reading Fool
Extras: My Interview with Dana Reinhardt, Interview at Interactive Reader, Interview at Bildungsroman
Planet Word Museum in Washington, DC
Hi there! I'm Kimberly Hirsh. My pronouns are she/ her/hers. I'm somebody's mom. I work as a school librarian. I have a PhD in information and library science. I love to read, play tabletop and video games, and make things. I used to perform in theater and improv comedy and I may one day again. I have been extremely online since 1993 and still enjoy tinkering on the web. I manage multiple chronic illnesses. I'm married to my kid's dad. We have a cat.
Want to get in touch? You can reach me by email.
Recent posts
Poetry Friday
In honor of my cat-related article up at Associated Content, I’m posting a cat poem today.
Had Tiberius Been a Cat
Cruel, but composed and bland,
Dumb, inscrutable and grand,
So Tiberius might have sat,
Had Tiberius been a cat.
Matthew Arnold 1822-1888
Tiberius was the second emperor of Rome. You can read more about him here. I’m not sure if this is the Tiberius the poet intended, but it sounds a lot like him.
Associated Content
Associated Content has published my article Unique Websites for Cat Lovers.
expecto patronum!
When my students ask me, "What can you DO with a Classics major?" I answer:
"Well, you pretty much have two options. You can either become a Latin teacher... or you can be a world famous novelist."
J. K. Rowling majored in the same thing I did, folks. But she's got more money. It's okay, though. I'm glad she did it, because it means her Latin is pretty darn accurate, excepting the nonsense words. And I can use things like the subject heading of this post to teach students the meaning of words like "accusative case."
Regardless of our respective tax brackets (which probably have no bearing to one another anyway as we live in different countries), J. K. makes me happy with her books. They are good and fun and I don't care if she's not Tolstoy. I don't require Tolstoy from a book. In fact, I put Tolstoy down a few times, and never finished Anna Karenina. I'll try again later.
All of this is to say, it's full-blown Harry Potter madness here in lecti-land. I am in the middle of crocheting myself a fabulous pink wig to wear to the release party in Hillsborough (yes,
What are you doing for the release of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows?
Literary Gifts
Barbara Johansen's ALA roundup mentioned a museum visit that sent me in search of one of my favorite DC museums, The National Museum of Women in the Arts. I decided to take a look in their shop and found this:
This is the Women Writers Umbrella. I love it! The writers on it are, starting with the very bottom and moving clockwise, Emily Dickinson, Mary Shelley, Louisa May Alcott, Virginia Woolf, Emma Lazarus, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Sylvia Plath, and Jane Austen. It's $27.50.
I also found in their store books by the Guerilla Girls, who I'm now reading all about and finding rather exciting.
There's also this fabulous Emily Dickinson scarf.
Harry Potter Screenings THIS THURSDAY
If you’re in Dallas, Portland, Sacramento, Raleigh/Durham, Minneapolis/St Paul, Pittsburgh, Atlanta or Orlando .. you can get into a sneak preview of the new HP movie.
Check out http://www.myspace.com/blackcurtain for more details on it.
A Brief Chapter in My Impossible Life
Simone’s family is perfect. Her father is a political cartoonist, her mother is an ACLU attorney, her brother is a high school freshman with great hair, and she’s a math whiz. Sure, she has dark hair, olive skin, and almond-shaped eyes while the rest of the family is blonde all over. But they’re still a family. And that’s what matters, right?
Simone’s known since early in her life that she’s adopted. She doesn’t know anything about her biological family, though, and what’s more, she’s never been curious about it. In spite of her lack of curiosity, Simone’s about to learn a lot more about her origins than she ever expected.
The central story in Dana Reinhardt’s debut novel A Brief Chapter in My Impossible Life deals with Simone’s discovery of her birth mother’s heritage, and the struggle she goes through to reconcile her Hasidic Jew history with her Atheist upbringing. Rivka, Simone’s birth mother, emerges as a force in Simone’s life that changes her perspective on everything in some way or another. Side stories include Simone’s best friend dealing with her recently changed body and subsequent, eventually unpleasant, sexual awakening, as well as a potential romance for Simone with a fellow staff member on the school paper.
Brief Chapter has a lot of great things going on. I’m reluctant to single one out as its best, so I’ll just list some. First, Simone’s voice is wonderful. Simone has a wry sense of humor, and is a deep thinker but not at all pretentious. Second is the delightful normalness of Simone’s family. They are not without flaws, but they aren’t ravaged by tragedy or creepily perfect. Third is the way the book handles the normal and important subject matter of young adult life - self-discovery, rapid change, understanding love and sex, crises of faith - while tying these themes into a larger story about the definition of family.
I would recommend Brief Chapter to just about any reader high-school aged or up. It has broad appeal, and is especially good for readers interested in adoption and interfaith issues.
Book: A Brief Chapter in My Impossible Life (Affiliate Link)
Author: Dana Reinhardt
Publisher: Wendy Lamb Books
Original Publication Date: 2006
Pages: 240
Age Range: Young Adult
Source of Book: Amazon.com
Other Blog Reviews: Tea Cozy, bookshelves of doom, interactivereader, Bildungsroman, Young Adult (& Kids) Books Central, propernoun.net
Extras: My Interview with Dana Reinhardt, Interview at Interactive Reader, Interview at Bildungsroman
Summer Blog Blast Tour, Day 7
The Summer Blog Blast Tour concludes with Justina Chen Headley at Finding Wonderland.
Colleen Mondor, grand organizer of the tour, reflects on its success at Chasing Ray.
Summer Blog Blast Tour, Day Six
Today's Interviews Tim Tharp at Chasing Ray Justina Chen Headley at Big A, little a Ysabeau Wilce at Shaken & Stirred Dana Reinhardt at Bildungsroman Julie Ann Peters at Finding Wonderland Cecil Castellucci at A Chair, A Fireplace & A Tea Cozy Bennett Madison at Bookshelves of Doom Holly Black at Seven Impossible Things Before Breakfast Justine Larbalestier at Hip Writer Mama Kirsten Miller at A Fuse #8 Production (Part Two)
Tomorrow’s Interviews Justina Chen Headley finishes out the week at Finding Wonderland
Poetry Friday
Revelations in the Key of K
Read the whole poem at PoetryFoundation.org.
K is my favorite letter.